Skip to content
LogIT Solutions LLC

MIFARE or proximity cards: which should you buy?

Match the cards your readers already read. For a new system, choose MIFARE DESFire EV2 or EV3: it is much harder to copy.

Topic
ID card printers and supplies
Reading time
6 min
Sources
4 checked
125 kHz0004521983 069,03487
AProximity card
MIFARE13.56 MHz · ISO 14443 A
BMIFARE card
CPlain PVC card
Short answer

If you already have card readers, buy the type they read: older readers often read 125 kHz proximity cards (EM4100 or HID Prox), newer ones read 13.56 MHz MIFARE. For a new system, choose MIFARE DESFire EV2 or EV3, because it is much harder to copy. Plain PVC cards have no chip and are for printed photo ID only.

Three kinds of card, in plain words

Almost every ID card is the same size as a bank card: CR80, which is 85.6 x 54 mm and usually 0.76 mm thick. What changes is what is inside the plastic.

Plain PVC, proximity and MIFARE cards compared
Plain PVCNothing: solid plasticNonePhoto ID, visitor badges and membership cards. Can carry a barcode, QR code or magnetic stripe.
Proximity (EM4100, HID Prox)A small chip and antenna that send one fixed ID number125 kHz (low frequency)Opening doors and clocking in on older readers
MIFARE ClassicA smart chip with memory and an older, broken security scheme13.56 MHz (high frequency)Doors, canteens and libraries on existing systems
MIFARE DESFire EV2 or EV3A smart chip with memory and strong AES encryption13.56 MHz (high frequency)New access control: one card for doors, canteen and printing

What kHz and MHz mean for you

kHz and MHz are the radio frequency the card and the reader use to talk to each other. A reader only hears cards on its own frequency, unless it is a dual-frequency (multi-technology) reader. That is why a new card can be "dead" on an old reader even though both look the same.

125 kHz vs 13.56 MHz: security

A 125 kHz proximity card sends the same number every time it comes near a reader. There is no secret key, so the number can be read and copied with cheap tools. Proximity cards are still common because many existing readers use them.

A 13.56 MHz MIFARE card is a smart card: it has memory and can protect its data with keys. NXP, the maker, says MIFARE DESFire EV3 uses hardware AES encryption with 128-bit keys, and that the chip is certified to Common Criteria EAL5+, an international security test level. DESFire EV3 also works in a compatibility mode with older DESFire EV2 and EV1 systems.

MIFARE Classic, the older and cheaper MIFARE card, uses a security scheme that researchers broke years ago. It still works, but it can be copied, so do not rely on it where security matters.

Copying risk, card by card

If your cards open doors, copying risk is the most important column here.

How hard is each card to copy?
Plain PVCThe printed design can be copied by anyone with a printerNonePhoto ID only, never as a door key
EM4100 or HID Prox (125 kHz)Yes, easily, with low-cost copiersNoneKeeping an existing 125 kHz system running
MIFARE Classic (13.56 MHz)Yes: its security has been brokenOlder, weak schemeLow-risk uses on existing systems
MIFARE DESFire EV2 or EV3Very hard, when the system uses the card keysAES-128New access control systems

The catch with secure cards

Many readers only read the card's serial number (the UID) and ignore its keys. Set up like that, even a DESFire card is not much safer than a proximity card. Ask your installer to use the card's secure mode, and check that your readers and software support DESFire before you order.

Will the card work with my reader?

This is the question that matters most when you reorder. Match the card to the readers you already have.

Reader to card compatibility
125 kHz EM readerEM4100-type proximity cardsEM4100 cards. HID Prox cards will usually not work.
HID Prox readerHID Prox cards in your site formatHID Prox cards with the same format and facility code as your current cards
13.56 MHz MIFARE readerMIFARE Classic, and often the serial number of DESFire cardsDESFire EV2 or EV3 if the reader and software support it; otherwise MIFARE Classic
Dual-frequency reader, such as the HID OMNIKEY 5427 CK for enrolling cardsBoth 125 kHz and 13.56 MHz cardsEither, but DESFire for new cards
Face or fingerprint terminal with a built-in card readerDepends on the modelCheck the datasheet, or send us the model and we will match the card

Format and facility code

HID Prox cards are programmed with a format (26-bit is common) and a site number called the facility code. New cards must match both, or your system will not accept them. You can find the values in your access software, and some are printed on the card.

How to find out which card you have

  • Look at the card. Proximity cards often have a number printed on the back, and some show the maker name, such as HID.
  • Look at the reader. The model name is on a label, usually on the back or under the cover.
  • Check your access control or attendance software. It often shows the card type and format.
  • Still not sure? Send us a photo of the card, the reader and its label on WhatsApp, and we will tell you which card to order.

Printing photos on smart cards

Yes, you can print on MIFARE and proximity cards, as long as they are thin, printable PVC cards (0.76 mm). Thick clamshell proximity cards, key fobs and stickers cannot go through a card printer. For example, HID's ISOProx II (1386) is a thin printable proximity card, while the ProxCard II (1326) is a thicker clamshell card.

The chip and antenna inside can leave the surface slightly uneven, so a retransfer printer gives the cleanest print on these cards. See retransfer vs direct-to-card printers.

Many printers can also encode (write to) the chip while printing, using an optional encoder. Swiftpro, for example, lists contact and contactless smart card encoding for the Swiftpro K30.

Which card should I buy?

Shop MIFARE cards, proximity cards or plain PVC cards, or use this table to decide first.

If this is your situation, buy this card
You are installing a new access control systemMIFARE DESFire EV2 or EV3, in a printable PVC card: see the DESFire EV3 card
Your readers are 125 kHz and you are keeping themProximity cards of the same type and format (EM4100 or HID Prox)
You only need a photo ID badge, with no doorsPlain white PVC cards: see the blank CR80 PVC card
One card should open doors and pay in the canteenMIFARE DESFire: it can hold separate applications on one chip
You are moving from proximity to MIFARE step by stepDual-technology cards (125 kHz and 13.56 MHz in one card) while both reader types are in use

Products in this guide

Add what you need to one quote list, then send it by WhatsApp or email. We reply with prices and stock.

Sources we checked

Product facts come from the makers' own pages. Rules come from official or legal sources.

  1. 1NXP MIFARE DESFire EV3nxp.com
  2. 2HID proximity cards and credentialshidglobal.com
  3. 3What is a CR80 card? (NameBadge) (opens in a new tab)namebadge.com
  4. 4Swiftpro K30 card printer (encoding and card sizes)swiftpro-printer.com

Questions buyers ask

Short, plain answers. If yours is not here, ask us on WhatsApp.

Are HID Prox and EM4100 cards the same?

No. Both work at 125 kHz, but they use different formats. An EM4100 reader usually cannot read HID Prox cards, and an HID Prox reader usually cannot read EM4100 cards. When you reorder, buy the same type and format you already use.

Is MIFARE Classic secure?

Not for doors where security matters. Its older security scheme has been broken, so cards can be copied. For new systems choose MIFARE DESFire EV2 or EV3, which use AES-128 encryption.

Can one reader read both 125 kHz and 13.56 MHz cards?

Only a dual-frequency, or multi-technology, reader. A standard reader hears one frequency only. Check the reader datasheet, or send us the model and we will tell you.

Can I print on MIFARE and proximity cards?

Yes, if they are thin printable PVC cards (CR80, 0.76 mm). Thick clamshell cards and key fobs cannot be printed. A retransfer printer gives the best result over the chip.

What size is a standard ID card?

CR80, the same as a bank card: 85.6 x 54 mm, usually 0.76 mm thick. Almost all ID card printers and card readers are made for this size.

Send us your list. We reply with prices and availability.

Not sure which one fits? Send us a photo of the site, the door or the card you use now. We suggest the parts, then supply, install and support them across the UAE.

WhatsApp us+971 50 889 5653
Company
LogIT Solutions LLC
Office
Dubai Silicon Oasis
In business
13+ years
Offices
UAE · India · Kenya